Just cause my silly intuition Gives me the bold permission to believe I must say somethin' that's been naggin' I don't mean to be braggin' But baby, please, listen Whoa, whoa It should've been me that loved you All this It should've been me that loved you All this time So when you look inside the mirror Does it get any clearer somethin's wrong Does he ever go past the surface Down where your real hurt is Down below your pretty face Whoa, whoa It should've been me that loved you All this It should've been me that loved you All this time So when your heart goes what's the matter I think I know the answer You know it's true everything I told you baby Whoa, whoa It should've been me that loved you All this It should've been me that loved you All this time